Skip to main content

Response to Dallas police officer killing Botham Jean

    In class, there were multiple stories people had heard to as to how a white police officer allegedly accidentally walked into an apartment not her own, saw a black man and shot him dead. The first story was that Amber Guyger, 4 year member of the Dallas police force, simply parked on the wrong floor after her shift, walked into the wrong apartment thinking it was hers, suspected Mr. Jean was a burglar, and shot him. This is the story most people know, the story that news organizations are telling. Another scenario being that Guyer and Jean were formerly in a relationship and the police officer was looking for revenge. This story is the less popular and most unlikely one. Before it was said in class, I hadn't heard anything about the two knowing each other prior to the shooting. Additionally, what is the likelihood that you and your ex live in the same building, you cant recognize their living space, and their family knew nothing of you? Somebody also heard that the police officer had her hands full of grocery's so she couldn't see that she was entering an apartment with a doormat not her own. But when she walked in, couldn't she see that all of the furniture and items in the apartment weren't hers? How would she be carrying groceries, open the door and be able to shoot somebody all at once? All of the scenarios have flaws that leave many questioning.
     In my opinion, the killing of Botham Jean was due to unfair bias by Amber Guygen. There was no logical reason for the police officer to pull her gun out in the first place. If she did enter the apartment thinking it was her own, most would immediately realize by the surroundings that it isn't theirs, apologize for the intrusion, and leave. Instead, she, the intruder, pulled a gun out on the alarmed and unarmed Botham Jean. Imagine how scary that would be, to have done nothing wrong yet randomly have a police officer walk into your home with no warning and pull out a gun. It is true, the different floors of the apartment complex may have looked very similar so that after a long day, going to the wrong floor is not an absurd concept. The police officer may have been so alarmed that there was somebody in "her" apartment she didn't even pay attention to the apartment interior to realize the furnishings weren't hers, but there is absolutely no excuse for pulling out a gun. Not even the fact that she was a police officer. Especially the fact that she was a police officer because that means she is trained to expect the unexpected. It seems like we never hear of stories like this with whites as the victims. It seems as if Amber Guyger assumed Botham Jean was doing something wrong for no reason other than that he was black and she couldn't pause in the moment to question the ingrained filter that because he was black, he must be doing something wrong. Regardless of how you choose to picture it, Botham Jean, a black man, was murdered while doing nothing but simply living his life, and that happens all too often.
   



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

News Media Critique

    Today, September16th, the Courier Journal posted an article about a Wyoming guide killed by a grizzly bear while looking for an elk in the Teton Wilderness. Click here to read the article. The report violated the element of good journalism newsworthiness.      In order to determine if something is newsworthy, the question, "Does it effect a lot of people for a long time?" must be answered. Without even reading the article, the answer to that question is clear. No, a random guide from Wyoming getting killed does not effect a lot of people for a long time. It was one occurrence that would only effect locals and close family. In general, this story was not deserving of publishing at all however, if it were more thematic it would possibly be relevant enough for publication. For example, if the report talked about a trend of grizzly bears attacking people very often in specific environments, that would effect a much larger group of people. It would make peopl...
Post a Comment
Read more

Non-newsworthy Story on WHAS

Today, WHAS posted on their website a story about a body being found in a duffle bag in Indiana, which authorities are now investigating. While this article tells citizens what's going on around them and it tells the truth, it is not newsworthy for numerous reasons. There is not a clear goal of telling people of the crime, it does not impact a lot of people for a long time, and the article only has quotes from the police, no witnesses, family members, or anybody else, making it one sided. While the death of the man found will most likely have a tremendous impact on his family, it does not impact the whole city. Furthermore, while there is freedom of speech, what if the family of the man, or the man, did not want his death publicly announced; especially considering the circumstances? Small crimes like these get reported all the time but are rarely remembered by people. They momentarily remind people of the daily dangers our world presents and for many people, crime is entertainment...
Post a Comment
Read more

Non-newsworthy Story on WHAS

WHAS posted an article on their website announcing that the band KISS' final tour will make a stop at the KFC Yum! Center here in Louisville. While I'm sure there is a decent amount of people who would like to know this, it is not newsworthy. This story will not effect a lot of people for a long time and it's just celebrity fluff. The concert will come and go and people will have a good time but it isn't life changing and not everybody likes KISS. Therefore this article already is only relevant to a small amount of people, those who like the band. While those people would want to know about this, the front spread of a news website is not the place for it. By putting this story on the front page WHAS stole room for other stories that would serve much more valuable to its viewers. Click here to see article.
Post a Comment
Read more